Marketers Fail to Understand and Reach Professional Women

by Nicole Crimaldi on June 8, 2010

Post image for Marketers Fail to Understand and Reach Professional Women

Yesterday I spent some time reading a white paper by Ad Age and published by Meredith called, “The Reality of the Working Woman.”

Let’s start with some interesting statistics

  • The number of women in the workforce have exceeded the number of males in the workforce.
  • Among working moms, 67% are breadwinners or co-breadwinners.
  • Today only 1 in 5 households has a “Stay-at-Home Mom.”
  • Today 1 out of 5 households are run by a single parent. In 1975 only 1 out of 10 were single-parent households.
  • Millenials are much more likely than Gen X’ers and Boomers to link their work with their sense of self and self-fulfillment. This statistic increases significantly for women earning over $70,000 per year.
  • Unlike Gen X’ers and Boomers, Millenial men reported doing the same exact amount of household work each day (72 minutes) as the average millennial female.
  • 82% of “pink slips” during the “Great Recession” went to men.

After reading these statistics, one thing came to mind: why the hell aren’t we seeing more hunky men vacuuming, cooking dinner and cleaning floors in advertisements?! 

Bring it.  Supposedly we have a vast majority of the buying power, so please appeal to us.  We are ready.   

Thankfully, the white paper pointed out one such advertisement- a 2008 TV commercial for the Chevy Traverse featuring a hunk who made an anniversary dinner reservation AND scrubbed the toilet all in one commercial.  The punch line was something about “not being too good to be true.” It’s nice to see an SUV commercial getting away from the “soccer mom” stereotype, but at the same time, making an anniversary dinner reservation and scrubbing a toilet does not deserve a standing ovation.  In my mind, it is just normal, every day life.

So if women have exceeded the number of men in the workforce and both genders spend the same amount of time doing household chores, why aren’t advertising campaigns reflecting this? AT ALL. 

AND, why the hell do we still use the term “working woman” as if it’s rare?  Most of us ARE working, so this is implied.  Plus, we’ve never used the term, “working man” before.

So here’s my opinion.

Dear Brand Managers and Marketers,

You are missing out on a huge opportunity here.  Please review the facts and get with the program.  Highlight the reality of single-parent households.  Stop making working Moms seem like the minority as they are now the majority.  Please don’t overstereotype the “working woman.”  Studies show that most of us love working and want to work.  And understand that just because we work, doesn’t mean we don’t have very traditional values.  In fact, surveys show our values are just as traditional as the Boomers and more traditional than Gen X’ers. 

We’d love you to portray your products as a “service” that helps us save time.

Also, if you feel so inclined, we’d love to see more hunky men and/or “Working Dads” in your commercials.  We find them fun to look at.  They are a great balance between fantasy and reality.

Thanks so much,

Millenial females everywhere, aka “Ms. Career Girls”

{ 12 comments… read them below or add one }

Kim June 8, 2010 at 12:53 pm

Here, here! Great post, and very interesting stats.

Reply

JillComm June 8, 2010 at 1:20 pm

I’ll go you one more and say that they need to stop featuring exclusively women in household cleaning ads. My fiance and I both work, and HE makes the household decisions on cleaning stuff. Occasionally I might be like “okay, we need a magic eraser”, but for the most part it’s all him.

But it’s ALWAYS women cheerfully cleaning in their spotless houses and minding their messy children. Husband or dad is almost never around, never mind being there exclusively.

Reply

Staci June 8, 2010 at 2:34 pm
Aimee June 8, 2010 at 1:58 pm

Amen sista!

Cute new pic.

Reply

Nicole Crimaldi June 8, 2010 at 6:17 pm

Thanks!

Reply

Nicole June 8, 2010 at 3:28 pm

This post makes me proud to be among the “Working Women” of America! We have more power than I think most of us realize.

Reply

Nicole Crimaldi June 8, 2010 at 6:20 pm

I agree. If I were a guy, I’d be almost intimidated to date women like us. In my opinion there has been a huge shift of power in our generation and not necessarily in the board room. The woman who “does it all” is hard for the typical guy to keep up with!

Reply

Douglas Trapasso June 8, 2010 at 10:34 pm

Dear Nicole:

Fascinating post! A couple of thoughts came to mind when reflecting on it.

For those of you who work in advertising, please chime in on this: aren’t most advertising agencies pretty diverse culturally and pretty close to 50-50 men/women at least at the entry level? Is it still a Mad Men style atmosphere at the top (but maybe a little less smoking now?) I am surprised that there are still retrograde commercials being made unless there’s still an Old Boy Network at the top.

Since we consume advertising in so many different forms of media, I would love to read some opinions on whether some formats offer more contemporary images in their ads than others. Is television advertising still behind the culture? Is the most cutting edge work done for online media?

And just for fun, check out some old commercials on YouTube. You’ll laugh (maybe cry!) at some of the outmoded technology and (unintentional?) political incorrectness!

Reply

Janet June 9, 2010 at 9:36 am

Great post! This really hits home for me because I grew up in a household where my parents shared household chores and outdoor chores equally. My mom helps with the outside stuff like shoveling and my dad will vacuum from time-to-time which is different than the typical gender breakdown of household duties. Advertising should definitely reflect that.

Reply

Grace Boyle June 9, 2010 at 12:15 pm

This is a great post and I love the statistics you’ve provided.

Reminds me of my friend Yvonne and her great blog, http://www.lipsticking.com/ talking about women and marketing to women.

Reply

Veronika Harbick June 10, 2010 at 12:04 pm

Really great post. It’s interesting how tv shows ARE starting to reflect this very well (thinking of Parenthood as an example) and there are some great brands that “get it.” Changing the marketing to women industry may be more about changing the definitions/ property portraying “working men” and “stay at home dads” rather than highlighting the changes in women.

Brands should listen up to and change their campaigns to appeal to us cause we do make the majority of purchase decisions. Like in the Sienna Swagger Wagon video “I’m better with the money, so I handle the bills.” :) http://bit.ly/cTmFml

PS. I just found your blog by way of http://www.lifewithoutpants.com. You have a great site! I’m glad I found you. Would love to talk more offline!

PPS. Grace – lipsticking is a great blog. I enjoy wonderbranding as well. We write one for Marketing to Moms called Mom~entum: http://bit.ly/an1l3k

Reply

Mike Handy June 22, 2010 at 12:49 pm

There are a ton of reasons why you don’t see men with Vacuum cleaners…
#1 Cultural norms… sorry but you can’t change that stuff over night no matter how much you might like to.
#2 You are looking at a data set that is experiencing a major and rapid shift.
#3 Some Women still want to think they are doing house chores even if they are not.
#4 Men will buy products because women endorse it.. cultural again.
#5 The time is even for chores (you should be seeing couples working together)
#6 Brands are rarely that progressive messaging takes time to shift
#7 Research: Much more research exists on how to sell cleaning products to women
#8 There isn’t a convincing reason to change.. the ads are still working (they will change when it stops working)
#9 Even if the classic market is shrinking its still huge!
#10 Your missing a maid data set (how many women that are high earners have a maid?)
#11 Single people actually need to clean less (look at the German data from 1980 to 2010)
#12 No major brand has made the shift (not even progressive brands)

Reply

Leave a Comment

Previous post:

Next post: